As host Jon Stewart noted — shortly before urging members of the Academy seated in the audience to indulge in a rare moment of self-congratulation — the looming awards show was a major impetus for getting Hollywood executives and the writers to come together earlier this month to hammer out a new contract. Ah, it's enough to make Norma Rae shed a tear (or at least two-time Oscar winner Sally Field).
And so a deal was forged, the show was saved and words of sparkling wit permeated Sunday's telecast. Well, maybe not. You would think it a perfect opportunity for a group of re-energized scribes to show off those highly valued skills, but we got the same canned banter we get year after year. The tired nature of the show was brought home on its 80th birthday by the extensive use of montage collections. Next up ... sound editing through the years! The best montage involved the use of binoculars and periscopes in cinema (if I had to choose one scene, I would go with Jodie Foster being hunted with night vision goggles in "The Silence of the Lambs"). I was expecting a montage of the previous montages to end the show, but I was let down (though seeing the Coen Brothers up there three times was its own sort of déjà vu).
Of course, we were told we should be grateful for what we got. The producers had only weeks to pull the show together. And they framed their hurried work in terms generally reserved for preparing a space shuttle for launch (I'd say this rocket went into orbit but some of its insulating foam has broken off).
But then, I have always loved Oscar night since I was a young teen. Maybe it was the way it caused my father to explode in conservative indignation, the only equal to Barbra Streisand and Bill Clinton (both of whom were referenced on the show Sunday) in his liberal pantheon of rage. "It's a bunch of faggot cocksuckers giving each other awards," he would say. Well, that's actually the Adult Video News awards; I love those, too, though I dare say they doesn't require the same formality in dress.
With the Oscars, you have Jack Nicholson beaming from the front row, people in hideous outfits and celebrities handing out prizes to each other, and there's bound to be amusement, intentional or otherwise. Here's a look at the night's highlights and lowlights ...
THE HOST: Stewart was suave and entertaining — less annoying that David Letterman, Chris Rock or Billy Crystal in the role, if not as sophisticated and at ease as Steve Martin on the Oscar stage, nor as delightfully crude as Whoopi Goldberg. Stewart's métier is real news — wars, diplomacy, politics — not the faux news of E! Entertainment Television (Marion Cotillard upsets Julie Christie for Best Actress!). He made a couple of interesting political jokes, but his biggest laugh involved the comparison of Cate Blanchett to a vicious pit bull (I always saw her playing an Australian sheepdog myself).
BEST SPEECH: Tilda Swinton, for taking note of Oscar's buttocks. He's been doing a lot of work in the gym the past couple years to slim down (well, in truth, the Academy wanted to save a few bucks on the gold plating) and only Ms. Swinton drew attention to his posterior, comparing it to her agent's. This colleague might have been the butt of her joke, but she promised to pass on that statue to him, at least. Let's hope it goes nowhere near his own rear (remember, statues should not be used as dildos).
WORST SPEECH: Javier Bardem (who was awesome as a gay poet in "Before Night Falls" a few years back), who spent half of it addressing his mother in Spanish. This distinction goes to him not as a rebuke of his speaking in another language, but instead for making me realize that the only words I can remember from my high school Spanish classes are gato, baño and cerveza — though I'd rather not use all three together in a sentence. How do you say "deadly cattle airgun" in Español, Javier?
BEST PRESENTER: Steve Carrell, for recognizing the social gravity of the three best animated feature nominees.
WORST PRESENTER: Tom Hanks. Of course, they bring in "Forrest Gump" to introduce our troops, who handed out a documentary short film award to a film about lesbians — somewhat ironic for this entity. Don't ask, don't tell and, darling, don't wear fatigues on the Red Carpet. Even if it is just an old throw rug stained with Iraqi children's blood, the fashion faux pas is still a bit tacky.
BEST LINE: "That's the good part of getting old. I don't recommend the other." — Production designer Robert Boyle, responding to a standing ovation for his lifetime achievement award. At 98, he proved it may be no country for old men, but on the Academy stage, age has its benefits (though don't tell that to a scowling Ruby Dee).
WORST LINE: That groaner from Stewart comparing Harrison Ford and a car dealership. Truthfully, I find the average car dealership to have more personality.
BEST SONG PERFORMANCE: None. They all sucked balls, even that one by that nice Irish pair (Where's Bono and the Edge when you need them?). Why couldn't they have spent the time re-creating the rudely overlooked avant garde score from "There Will Be Blood"?
BIGGEST SNUB (AWARD): The Oscars lost all credibility the moment I found out that Sarah Silverman's groundbreaking "I'm F***ing Matt Damon" was omitted from the live short film category. I fear there's not much hope for Jimmy Kimmel's sequel, "I'm F***ing Ben Affleck," at next year's ceremony — unless he can remake it as a cartoon and campaign for it in the best animated short category.
BIGGEST SNUB (DEATH MONTAGE): Brad Renfro. The "Ghost World" actor was omitted from the role call of the recently departed. It wasn't the opiates. Heath Ledger was mixing more meds than an overworked pharmacist and he got the pimp obit spot at the end. But Brad was nowhere to be found. Official word from the Academy had it that he wasn't a big enough star. But the young actor deserved a spot alone for his conflicted strip tease at a gay bar in the revenge film "Bully."
BEST UNEXPECTED WIN: "The Bourne Ultimatum" taking three technical awards (editing, sound effects editing, sound mixing ... Yay! It can be part of next year's sound mixing winners montage!) It should have been up for some bigger awards, but at least it paid some recognition to a genre that rarely gets credit when done well. And it's rarely done as well as this. The next best thing to f***ing Matt Damon? Seeing him jump over rooftops while wearing a tank top (though sadly not the lamée top Ben Affleck was wearing in his short film).
BEST EXPECTED WIN: Daniel Day-Lewis crushing the competition in the Best Actor race. I was hoping for one moment the honorable thespian would hoist his statue, give thanks to the Academy and then tell the audience of more than one billion people (unfortunately only about 10 of those people have seen the wonderful "There Will Be Blood") that "this award is brought to you by McDonald's milkshakes! Chocolate, vanilla or strawberry, I'll drink your milkshake, so you better buy two at McDonald's. And don't forget the value meals. There will be bargains at McDonald's!" Alas, the noble Brit kept things high-brow and dedicated the award to family. Yawn. Why not dedicate it to Heath Ledger again? (Or better yet, show Brad Renfro some thespian love. Don't tell me you didn't study his work in "Bully" while preparing for your role in "Gangs of New York.")
BEST AWARD GIVEN TO AN ERSTWHILE EROTIC DANCER: Diablo Cody for "Juno," just edging out multiple winner Ethan Coen.
BEST GAY MOMENT: Jon Stewart offering the indelible image of two winners having their Oscar statues make out with each other (well, they have been working out lately ...). If only it could have been the sound mixing team, it could have been an orgy. Meanwhile, that lesbian film won best documentary short and "No Country for Old Men" producer Scott Rudin thanked his male partner (of the intimate kind, rather than the production end ... unless the Coen Brothers want to say something — and I'm pretty sure, if his comments on state are any indication, Ethan isn't talking, though I hear he gave a good table dance back in the day).
WORST GAY MOMENT: The Red Carpet. Need I say more?